Last week, President Trump fired both Democratic FTC Commissioners Alvaro Bedoya and Rebecca Slaughter – yet another move to consolidate executive power and exert control over independent agencies. The legal and political fallout is expected to be substantial, setting off months or even years of litigation that could potentially result in redefining the autonomy of independent commissions.
The firings follow a broader effort by the administration to assert control over independent agencies. Last month, Acting Solicitor General Sarah Harris sent a letter to Senator Richard Durbin (D-Ill.) signaling the DOJ’s intention to ask the Supreme Court to overturn Humphrey’s Executor, a legal precedent limiting the ability for the president to fire members of independent agencies at will. Trump also signed an executive order in February requiring independent agencies like the FTC, FCC and SEC to submit proposed regulations to the White House for review and consultation.
Expected rulings on Humphrey’s Executor could fundamentally alter the structure of independent commissions, rendering them mere extensions of presidential policy making. For the FTC in particular, this upheaval may cast doubt on the Commission’s very governance, with Democrats in Congress likely to contest the validity of decisions made without a full slate of commissioners. If the courts agree, it could render decisions made without commissioners Bedoya and Slaughter legally suspect.